Our Lodge
Our History
How a handful of Hilliard Masons, after three failed petitions, founded Avery Lodge in 1873.
On May 31, 1871, a petition to establish a new Masonic lodge in Hilliard, Ohio was presented to Urania Lodge No. 311. It was signed by Brothers Davidson, Hatton, White and Avery. The motion was defeated. A new petition presented on June 14, 1871 was declared illegal. On July 26, 1871 another petition, for a lodge to be named Zion Lodge, was found to be incorrect.
On July 9, 1873 a petition signed by Brother Seeds of Lockbourne Lodge No. 232 and Brothers Avery, Glover, Black and Hatton of Urania Lodge No. 311 was presented to establish a new lodge in Hilliard, to be named Avery Lodge. It is assumed the lodge was named in honor of Brother Pelatiah Avery because he was the eldest of the petitioners. A ballot was taken, and the motion passed.
Working under dispensation
In August 1873 a petition was presented to the Grand Lodge asking for a dispensation to open a lodge of Master Masons in Hilliard. Grand Master Most Worshipful Brother Asa H. Battin granted it on August 19, 1873, and appointed the following officers to serve until a charter was granted:
- Worshipful Master: J. T. Black
- Senior Warden: William Hatton
- Junior Warden: J. E. Moling
On August 21, 1873 the brethren opened a lodge of Master Masons in due form with these additional officers:
- Treasurer: S. J. Wooley
- Secretary: R. Z. Seeds
- Senior Deacon: Clark Glover
- Junior Deacon: Clark Barlow
- Tyler: Alexander Davidson
Other charter members present were Edward S. Churchman and Pelatiah Avery of Urania Lodge No. 311, and Henry Culp of Blendon Lodge No. 339.
While the lodge was working under dispensation, Mr. R. M. Merryman became the first person to request membership on August 22, 1873, followed by Mr. G. W. Elzey on September 4. At the Grand Lodge Sessions in October 1873, the application for a charter was rejected because the lodge had been working for only two months and had only two candidates.
The charter
On November 18, 1873, Mr. John Hart petitioned for membership, and on January 20, 1874, Mr. John Koehler did as well. At the 1874 Grand Lodge Sessions, another application for a charter was approved. On October 21, 1874, Avery Lodge No. 493 was granted its charter and constituted a lodge of Free and Accepted Masons.
An election was held on December 1, 1874, and these brethren were installed on December 15:
- Worshipful Master: James E. Moling
- Senior Warden: R. Z. Seeds
- Junior Warden: E. S. Churchman
- Treasurer: P. S. Avery
- Secretary: G. W. Elzey
- Senior Deacon: Clark Glover
- Junior Deacon: Alexander Davidson
- Chaplain: Rev. A. R. Miller
- Tyler: J. M. Gutches
The first to seek membership after the charter was granted were the Reverend A. R. Miller and Dr. James M. Merryman, both by affiliation. The initiation fee was $25.00 for all three degrees, and dues were $3.00 a year.
Our homes on Main Street
The lodge first met on the north side of Main Street, between Franklin Street and the railroad tracks, at 4009 Main Street. The building was built by Mr. John Westerweller as a storeroom; the lodge added the second story as its lodge room. The first floor later became the Hilliard Post Office.
In December 1918 the lodge bought the property at 3980 Main Street from the local Board of Education for $1,830.00. A committee of Brothers E. J. Van Schoyck, Jacob Hommon and Paul Wood oversaw remodeling the four-room elementary school into a Masonic hall. The men who helped were paid $0.50 an hour. Past Grand Master Most Worshipful Brother Charles J. Pretzman dedicated the building on July 1, 1919, with about 95 members and visitors present. The lodge had 101 members at the time.

Growth and milestones
- July 1, 1969: a program at the lodge hall marked 50 years of Masonry in the building.
- Early 1960s: several years of rapid growth, averaging 16–18 new members a year.
- September 28, 1974: the lodge was rededicated for its 100th anniversary, led by Grand Orator RWB Jerry O. Rasor, with 64 members and visitors attending.
- 1980: membership peaked at 427.
- 2024: Avery Lodge marked 150 years in Hilliard.
Adapted from a history written by John E. Hart, Secretary.